Skip to main content
Brittany Kosin for Liberty logo
BRITT 4 LIBERTY / Libertarian Newswire · National · Political Parties

Another Mises Caucus Newsletter, More Factual Errors, and the Same Old Promises

The Mises Caucus has a revolutionary new idea.

Take over the Libertarian Party. Again.

Apparently, the first revolution wasn’t revolutionary enough.

Michael Heise and his political allies are back, this time proposing to rename the Libertarian Party the American Liberty Party, rewrite its governing documents, and recruit Republican Congressman Thomas Massie for a presidential campaign he hasn’t agreed to undertake.

In its latest newsletter, the caucus accuses the Libertarian Party of being controlled opposition, alleges that current leadership is sabotaging growth, and asks supporters to finance another political transformation.

Same playbook. Different packaging. Another donation link.

And a rather inconvenient historical record.

The Revolution That Already Happened

In 2022, the Mises Caucus successfully took control of national party leadership, promising growth, professionalism, and political relevance.

Then the numbers arrived.

According to Reason, monthly revenue fell from $125,542 in April 2022 to $84,710 in April 2024—a 32.5% decline.

Sustaining membership dropped from approximately 16,200 to 12,211 during the same period.

By January 2026, membership had fallen to 8,989.

The figures don’t prove that every loss resulted from caucus decisions. But the decline during its period of national control is hardly irrelevant to its latest diagnosis of party failure.

The Mises Caucus lost its dominant position at the May 2026 convention. Evan McMahon and his newly elected team have been in office less than six months.

Four years of organizational decline cannot reasonably be laid at the feet of an administration that inherited it.

The Financial Scandals Missing From the Newsletter

The newsletter questions current leadership while omitting the troubles surrounding former Chair Angela McArdle.

In August 2025, the LNC formally censured McArdle following an investigation into undisclosed conflicts of interest and misuse of donor funds.

The investigation examined $49,600 paid to Freedom Calls LLC, associated with her domestic partner, Austin Padgett.

In October 2026, the LNC filed a civil lawsuit against McArdle and Padgett alleging financial misconduct and seeking more than $250,000 in relief.

The allegations remain contested. Neither the censure nor the lawsuit constitutes a criminal conviction.

Meanwhile, the Federal Election Commission previously fined Mises PAC $7,907 for a late financial report. The civil penalty was paid.

Not exactly the background one expects to be omitted from a lecture on institutional accountability.

Amanda Griffiths and the Curious Definition of Sabotage

The newsletter accuses LNC Vice Chair Amanda Griffiths and LP Alliance of sabotaging party growth.

Its evidence includes an authentic Discord screenshot showing a message attributed to Griffiths suggesting that users subscribe to American Liberty Party emails and collectively report them as spam.

What the screenshot does not establish that the suggested campaign was carried out, that any email service was suspended, or that LP Alliance formally authorized the tactic.

More importantly, the American Liberty Party is not the Libertarian Party. It is an initiative seeking to take over and rebrand it.

The proposed interference targeted the Mises Caucus-backed recruitment effort, not the Libertarian Party’s own membership operations.

Opposition to the rebranding could reflect an effort to preserve the LP’s identity, although the screenshot alone does not establish Griffiths’s motivation.

And interfering with ALP communications would not, by itself, prove sabotage of the Libertarian Party.

The newsletter stretches the accusation further, invoking international political influence without establishing the alleged connection.

One Discord conversation has somehow become an international conspiracy.

That’s quite a promotion.

San Francisco, New Hampshire, and Selective Accountability

The caucus also condemns the Libertarian Party of San Francisco’s statements opposing age-of-consent laws.

Those statements warranted condemnation.

But national Chair Evan McMahon publicly rejected them in October. The San Francisco affiliate has since reportedly apologized and placed its social media account under new management.

And what of New Hampshire?

That affiliate endorsed Donald Trump in 2024 despite the Libertarian Party having its own presidential nominee.

The new LNC voted 15–2 to disaffiliate New Hampshire in May 2026. The Judicial Committee upheld that decision 7–0 in August.

At the national convention, a New Hampshire delegate was also accused of striking an Illinois woman delegate. His credentials were revoked, and New Hampshire subsequently opened an investigation.

Where was the comparable public outrage from Mises Caucus leadership?

A review of its published defense of New Hampshire’s affiliate status did not identify a discussion of that reported incident. That does not establish that no condemnation was issued elsewhere.

Still, the contrast raises questions about consistency.

The nonaggression principle shouldn’t require checking someone’s caucus membership first.

First Dave Smith. Now Thomas Massie.

Perhaps the most familiar part of the newsletter is its presidential strategy.

In 2022, the Mises Caucus anticipated Dave Smith becoming its presidential standard-bearer in 2024.

Smith didn’t run.

In a June 2024 statement, then-caucus Chairman Aaron Harris acknowledged that Smith had been the original plan. The movement subsequently backed Michael Rectenwald, who lost the nomination to Chase Oliver.

Now the caucus is building another strategy around Thomas Massie.

Except Massie hasn’t committed either.

During a November 12 Breaking Points interview, Massie discussed the proposed Libertarian takeover alongside other recruitment efforts and explicitly stated that he wasn’t participating in those plans.

The caucus claims more than 6,000 American Liberty Party registrations.

Impressive, perhaps. But an email address isn’t a convention delegate, and a presidential recruitment campaign isn’t a presidential candidacy.

The cast has changed. The unresolved question hasn’t.

Even the Congressional Math Needs Work

The newsletter claims Massie’s effort to impeach Pete Hegseth was blocked because seven Democrats missed the vote.

According to the House Clerk, 11 Democrats and seven Republicans did not vote.

The 211–204 vote concerned referring the impeachment resolution to committee, not directly impeaching Hegseth.

The congressional record is available to everyone. Apparently, it didn’t make the newsletter’s reading list.

The Same Keys, a Different Sign

The Mises Caucus says the Libertarian Party is broken and needs repurposing.

Its proposed solution is to acquire the party’s ballot access, affiliates, and infrastructure—the very institutions it dismisses as ineffective.

It also contemplates using that infrastructure to assist Massie should he pursue a Republican presidential campaign.

That leaves a fundamental question about the party’s independent identity.

The caucus took power in 2022, experienced substantial organizational setbacks during its leadership period, and lost its dominant national position in 2026.

Now it wants another opportunity.

The newsletter offers a new name, another prospective presidential candidate, and renewed fundraising appeals.

What it offers less clearly is an explanation of what would change operationally.

A recycled revolution is still recycled. And changing the sign on the door doesn’t erase the record of the people asking for the keys.


Editor’s note: The Discord screenshot is authentic, but it does not establish whether the suggested spam-reporting activity occurred or received organizational authorization. Allegations in the McArdle civil litigation remain contested. The reported convention altercation has not been established by a final criminal judgment.

Reporting sources: Reason · Libertarian Party · Mises Caucus · Independent Political Report · FEC · U.S. House Clerk

STAY INFORMED

Libertarian news, original reporting, new articles, and updates from Brittany Kosin.
Brittany Kosin for Liberty
Independent reporting, liberty-focused resources, and practical tools for people who believe in individual freedom, accountability, and a stronger future.
© 2026 Brittany Kosin. All rights reserved.